Showing posts with label bug. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bug. Show all posts

Safari sees through filename extension lies

Here is the main text of a bug report I filed this morning with Apple:

If I use Photoshop to save a PSD file, and then rename that file so that its filename extension indicates it's a GIF file, I've just created a bogus file which most applications will not be able to figure out. Firefox and Internet Explorer display empty boxes. Photoshop itself cannot open such a file, even though internally the file is in Photoshop's native format.

Unlike most applications, Safari figures out that the filename extension is a lie and displays the image correctly. Ordinarily, I would pat Safari on the back for being better than everybody else. However, in this case, it can cause confusion.

Suppose you're learning web publishing and you make the mistake of thinking you can change a filename extension and the file will be magically translated into the corresponding format. This is a pretty common mistake among learners. If you are authoring a site with Safari as your test engine, you can "get away with" this mistake. However, when you test with other browsers, you discover your images don't work. You get empty boxes.

Here's why this is a particularly toxic situation: Part of learning web publishing is learning HTML. While you're learning, you make lots of HTML mistakes, and HTML mistakes resulting in empty boxes instead of images are quite common. When you see the empty boxes caused by the filename extension mistake, you assume there's a problem in your HTML, and you stare at it for hours, scratching your head, getting nowhere, because your HTML is perfect.

So, as annoying as it may seem, I am asking you to make Safari stupider. Please make it stop seeing through filename extension lies. No other app does it, and nobody makes Safari-specific sites, so there's no upside, and the downside is that it confuses people who are trying to learn web publishing.

Mac OS X 10.4 parental controls vs. Microsoft Office 2004

Tonight, I set up Microsoft Office 2004 to run in a Simple Finder configuration under the parental controls of Mac OS X 10.4 (Tiger), but it took a lot longer to get running than it should have. The first application I tried to enable was Microsoft Word. Although the parental controls window clearly showed Word as having been enabled, Word did not appear in the applications window when I logged in as the user in question. After many frustrating attempts to rectify the situation, I finally got lucky. I enabled the full Finder and launched Word, which went through its "first run" ritual for the user in question. Office applications, of course, need to perform this ritual once for each user. After I logged out and back in again, Word appeared in the Simple Finder window. My theory is that the parental controls in Tiger know that this configuration is not capable of supporting the first run of an Office application, and so they quietly hide the app from the user. This is a user-hostile way to handle the issue; I would have preferred to see Word try and fail to perform its first run ritual.

turn off Visual Studio 2005 automatic manifest resource generation in converted projects

When Visual Studio 2005 upgrades an old project, it turns on a setting which tells the linker to create a manifest resource in your program file. This resource seems to express a dependency on a DLL version of the C/C++ standard libraries. This causes the system to refuse to load your program unless said DLL is present. Your users will get an error indicating something about an invalid configuration and suggesting they reinstall. Apparently, the relevant libraries are not present on Windows XP SP2 (I haven't checked Vista), which causes the system to believe it should not even try to run some otherwise perfectly good programs.

This is a particularly vexing because some applications, including some bundled with Windows, install these libraries, and it can be difficult to figure out why some systems fail and others do not. One such application is, you guessed it, VS2005, so you will never be able to reproduce this problem on the system with which you built your program. Another seems to be Internet Explorer 7, so anybody who's got automatic updates turned on won't be able to reproduce this problem, either. Anybody who's still running IE6 (or earlier) without VS2005 probably will not be able to run your program.

Adding insult to injury, my programs already contain carefully constructed manifest resources and/or have carefully chosen linker options so that they don't take external dependencies which may or may not be present on deployment systems.

Fortunately, the fix was simple. There's a new linker option which controls generating this manifest resource. I turned it off and things went back to normal. It seems I could also have directed users to the Microsoft web page where they may download the C/C++ runtime libraries from VS2005. (Perhaps Microsoft ought to add these libraries to Windows Update.) Or, it seems, I could have redistributed these libraries with my programs (after deciding I am compatible with the relevant legalese).

I understand why Microsoft would want to add the capability of generating a manifest resource to the linker, but I don't understand why they would want to turn it on by default in such an annoying way. This cost me hours. It's partly my fault for not reading the upgrade report carefully; it did mention something about manifests. Had I been super-careful, I would have looked deeper into this potential problem and perhaps found the actual problem earlier. But since it didn't cause any trouble right away, I was lulled into a false sense of security that Microsoft had not done anything risky to my project.

tooltip message handling nightmare abated

I recently spent a boggling amount of time — a couple of weeks, on and off — second-guessing Microsoft's tooltips message handling code. Not only does it have at least one nasty bug, but it seems designed to make easy cases easy, which is a diplomatic way of saying it tends to make anything beyond that very difficult. Do try it, and see if it works for you, but if you spend more than a day scratching your head and trying to overcome limitations, my recommendation is to skip TTM_RELAYEVENT, turn off all tool flags other than TTF_TRACK and TTF_ABSOLUTE, and get real cozy with TTM_TRACKACTIVATE and TTM_TRACKPOSITION. Oh, and write your own equivalent of TTF_SUBCLASS. Once I realized I ought to give this approach a try, I was out of the woods in just a couple days, and I've written some C++ classes which will relieve me from ever having to deal with this madness again.